• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to secondary sidebar

Alston & Bird Privacy, Cyber & Data Strategy Blog

  • Home
  • Services
  • Events
  • Contacts

Lenovo Wins Second Motion to Dismiss in Adware Class Action

February 2, 2018 By Gavin Reinke

By Jay Repko

A California district court recently dismissed—for the second time—consumer claims that technology giant Lenovo Inc. violated New York’s Deceptive Acts and Practices Statute by selling laptops with preinstalled VisualDiscovery software that allegedly invades users’ privacy and exposes users to security breaches.  In reaching this decision, Judge Haywood S. Gilliam, Jr. concluded that dismissal was warranted for two reasons: (i) the plaintiffs lacked standing and (ii) the plaintiffs failed to adequately allege actual damages.

By its very terms, New York’s Deceptive Acts and Practices Statute prohibits only those deceptive acts and practices that occur in the state.  However, the named plaintiffs did not allege that they were New York residents, nor did the plaintiffs allege that any of the deceptive conduct at issue occurred in New York.  As a result, the plaintiffs were left to argue that they had standing based on the New York choice-of-law provisions in the sales agreements for the affected laptops.  The Court disposed of this argument stating that the plaintiffs had “improperly conflate[d] choice-of-law with statutory standing.”

The Court then concluded that even if the plaintiffs had statutory standing, the plaintiffs’ claims could not survive Lenovo’s motion to dismiss because the plaintiffs had not pled sufficient facts to establish actual damages.  While the plaintiffs argued that they overpaid for the laptops and “did not receive the full value of their purchase, i.e., a laptop free of malware,” the Court found these arguments insufficient because the plaintiffs had not alleged (i) that their laptop performance was actually degraded or (ii) what their performance expectations were pre-purchase.

Judge Gilliam’s second without-prejudice dismissal of the plaintiffs’ New York statutory claims is the latest ruling in a consolidated class action against Lenovo and the developer of the VisualDiscovery software, Superfish, Inc.  According to the plaintiffs, the VisualDiscovery software allows Superfish to monitor its users’ online behavior so that it can effectively tailor advertisements to their interests.  Despite their allegations, however, the plaintiffs will be unable to move forward with their New York statutory claims unless they can cure their standing and damages flaws in a second amended complaint by February 28.

The case is In re: Lenovo Adware Litigation, No. 5:15-md-02624, Northern District of California.

Filed Under: Cybersecurity, Data Breach, Data Security, Online Privacy, Privacy, Privacy Litigation Tagged With: Class Action, cybersecurity, Litigation, US State Law

About Gavin Reinke

Gavin focuses his practice on complex commercial litigation and class actions. His experience includes representing businesses in privacy-related class actions, products liability litigation, financial services litigation and complex construction defect litigation.

[Read Bio]

Primary Sidebar

This blog is a service of Alston & Bird’s Privacy, Cyber & Data Strategy team and focuses on key data privacy and data security issues.


Receive email notifications when new posts are added.

Receive email notifications when new posts are added.


THE DIGITAL DOWNLOAD
Click here to see the editions

PRIVACY & CYBER EVENTS
Click here to see upcoming and past events

PRIVACY & CYBER MAILINGS
Click here to sign up

@ALSTONPRIVACY
Click here to follow us on Twitter

Secondary Sidebar

Categories

Recent Posts

  • President Biden Issues Executive Order on America’s Supply Chains
  • Eleventh Circuit Holds Risk of Future Harm Does Not Establish Article III Standing
  • European Commission Adopts Draft UK Adequacy Decision
  • NYDFS Issues Best Practices for Cyber Insurance Risk Management
  • Fifth Circuit Decision Raises Cyber Enforcement Complications for the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
Copyright © 2021 · Alston & Bird · All Rights Reserved. Privacy.